请问大家这种情况下修改后的论文还会回到这位审稿人手中吗

2025-04-26 21:28:54
推荐回答(1个)
回答1:

Based on the comments and recommendations of 3 reviewers, the Associate Editor feels that your paper is not acceptable for publication in its present form. I agree with this decision and have concluded that the paper must be resubmitted, taking into account the detailed remarks of the reviewers. 按这意思应该是大修了,不过没给deadline 三个审稿人,其中两个都是不痛不痒的意见,大多数是对文章没讲明白的地方提出疑问,针对性修改没有问题,但是第三个审稿人的意见中没有提出疑问,都是要reject的意思,以下举出两条: 论文给出的结果确实不敢说特别好,不过还是把以前发表的成果提高了不少,如果一定要拿出来和世界最先进的比自然是unconvincing,要不然也不会投这儿,但是这期刊影响因子也就0.2,何必非要装得那么清高呢举报删除此信息