Journal of membrane science投稿被拒后求助

2025-03-13 02:43:17
推荐回答(1个)
回答1:

要么提升质量,修改后重提交,要么找个低档次的吧,这还能有什么投机取巧的方法?

journal of membrane science这个杂志审稿周期为1个月。结果呢一个编辑审稿1个月后告诉我要我加一个数据,然后feel free to resubmit the paper. 11月底的时候我就submit了文章,12月8号under review,大概1月26号的时候编辑说要我再继续推荐3个审稿人,我又推荐了3个,大概3月16号收到来信,如下:
I have made numerous attempts to obtain a another review from a second
referee, including sending multiple reminder letters. Unfortunately, I have
only one review. To prevent undue delay for you, I have decided to proceed
based on one review.
A Reviewers has now commented on your paper and comments are appended below.
You will see that the referee is advising that you revise your manuscript.
The referee comments that the manuscript could reasonably be shortened, and
that the advantages of your system should be framed with respect to prior
literature. Some of the SEMs could also be included in the Supplementary
Information. Please consider the comments and suggestions carefully and
incorporate the appropriate changes into your revised manuscript.
If you decide to revise the work, please submit a list of changes or a
rebuttal against each point which is being raised when you submit the
revised manuscript. In order to determine the extent of your revision and
facilitate the re-review process should it be necessary, please provide a
detailed point-by-point response and a clear indication of where changes
were made to the original manuscript, by indicating all changes with colored
text.

说明编辑对你的文章蛮感兴趣,也比较负责,还是按照他的意见,积极做吧,很有希望

你这个文章,让你修稿,接收的几率很大。条件是:你必须按照审稿人的意见修稿,半点不能马虎。写回复信的时候,一定要客气。祝你好运